Office Overview

Mastering Counter Tenders: Strategies for Success in M&A

– Understanding Counter Tenders: A Key Element in M&A
– Exploring Counter Tender Strategies and Tactics
– Real-life Examples and Case Studies Illustrating the Impact of Counter Tenders

Counter tenders play a crucial role in the realm of mergers and acquisitions (M&A), yet they are often overlooked or misunderstood. In this comprehensive guide, we’ll delve into the intricacies of counter tenders, providing insights into their significance and strategies for navigating them successfully.

Understanding Counter Tenders: A Key Element in M&A

1. Definition: A counter tender, also known as a competing tender or rival bid, is a response made by a target company to a tender offer made by an acquiring company in an M&A transaction. It serves as a strategic maneuver employed by the target company to solicit better terms or alternative offers from potential acquirers, thereby maximizing shareholder value.

2. Purpose: The primary purpose of a counter tender is to ensure that the target company’s shareholders receive the best possible deal in an M&A transaction. By inviting competing bids, the target company aims to create a competitive environment that drives up the acquisition price and enhances shareholder returns. Additionally, counter tenders provide the target company’s board of directors with leverage to negotiate favorable terms and conditions with the acquiring company.

3. Process: The process of initiating a counter tender typically involves the target company’s board of directors evaluating the terms of the acquiring company’s offer and determining whether it adequately reflects the company’s value and growth prospects. If deemed necessary, the board may authorize the launch of a counter tender, which involves soliciting alternative bids from other potential acquirers or engaging in negotiations to improve the terms of the existing offer.

Exploring Counter Tender Strategies and Tactics

Counter tender strategies vary depending on the specific circumstances of each M&A transaction and the objectives of the target company. Let’s explore some common strategies and tactics employed by target companies in response to tender offers:

1. Engaging Competing Bidders: One strategy involves actively soliciting competing bids from other potential acquirers to create a bidding war. This approach puts pressure on the acquiring company to sweeten its offer or risk losing the deal to a competitor offering more attractive terms.

2. Negotiating Better Terms: Another tactic is to engage in negotiations with the acquiring company to improve the terms of the original offer. This may involve seeking a higher purchase price, better deal structure, or enhanced shareholder protections to maximize value for the target company’s shareholders.

3. Exploring Alternative Transactions: In some cases, the target company may explore alternative transactions, such as strategic partnerships or divestitures, as an alternative to accepting the acquiring company’s offer. This allows the target company to consider all available options and choose the path that best aligns with its long-term strategic objectives.

Real-life Examples and Case Studies Illustrating the Impact of Counter Tenders

To better understand the significance of counter tenders in M&A transactions, let’s examine real-life examples and case studies showcasing their impact:

Example 1: Qualcomm’s Counter Tender Against Broadcom
In 2018, Qualcomm, a leading semiconductor company, launched a counter tender against Broadcom in response to Broadcom’s hostile takeover bid. Qualcomm’s board of directors deemed Broadcom’s offer undervalued and initiated a campaign to solicit alternative bids, ultimately leading to the termination of Broadcom’s acquisition attempt.

Example 2: Twenty-First Century Fox’s Counter Tender Against Comcast
In 2018, Twenty-First Century Fox engaged in a counter tender against Comcast following Comcast’s bid to acquire the company’s assets. Fox’s board of directors determined that Comcast’s offer was not superior to Disney’s existing bid and opted to pursue negotiations with Disney instead, ultimately resulting in Disney acquiring Fox’s entertainment assets.

These examples highlight how counter tenders can influence the outcome of M&A transactions and shape the strategic direction of companies.

Counter tenders are a critical aspect of M&A transactions, allowing target companies to maximize shareholder value and negotiate favorable terms with acquiring companies. By understanding the significance of counter tenders and employing effective strategies and tactics, companies can navigate M&A transactions successfully and achieve their strategic objectives.